Shareholders grill Spark over lacklustre run

Source: Radio New Zealand

BCFNZ chair Justine Smyth said the foundation had been asking for the breast screening age to be raised to 74 for the past eight years.

Chairperson Justine Smyth says she will step down as chairperson and board member within the next 12 months. Photo: Supplied / BCFNZ

Shareholders in telecommunications company Spark have grilled the board on its poor performance over the past couple of years.

Spark chairperson Justine Smyth told shareholders at the annual meeting the company was on track to deliver a flat underlying profit of just over a billion dollars in the year ending June 2026, which was little changed from the year earlier, assuming the 75 percent sale of its data centres went ahead.

Smyth also said she would step down as chairperson and board member within the next 12 months.

The company also laid out a strategy that renewed its focus on connectivity rather than an ambition to deliver broader digital services.

Chief executive Jolie Hodson said the telco had put in place a programme to drive mobile growth with new high data plans, brand campaigns and pricing.

“This is moving the dial and Spark remains the #1 mobile provider by some distance, with 41.4 percent total market revenue share,” Hodson said.

However, she said broadband remained competitive, with connections down 3.8 percent.

Hodson said the fresh strategy would see Spark partner with others to deliver key services, though it would retain control over all components of critical assets that deliver competitive advantage.

“Our new technology delivery model includes four key partnerships which allow us to leverage our partners’ global expertise and investments in AI and automation to deliver better customer experiences in a more efficient way,” Hodson said.

The transformation had resulted in $85m of savings in the second half of the June 2025 year.

“This ensures we are in a stronger position as we move into FY26 and embark on our new five-year strategy.

“After the first quarter of FY26, trading is tracking in line with our expectations, with the new brand campaign, iPhone launch, and price increases supporting mobile service revenue growth.”

She said a productivity programme was also on track, with significant savings delivered across labour and cost savings.

“Our focus over the next five years is on returning Spark to its history of stable performance, with predictable free cash flow and growing dividends over time.

“We have a proven track record of cost discipline and adapting our business when we need to, and portfolio management to support shareholder returns.

“The past couple of years have been incredibly challenging, and I acknowledge the impact this has had on our shareholders. We have taken decisive action to transform our business within this changing environment, and I am committed to seeing this through and returning Spark to growth,” Hodson said, as she offered herself for re-election to Spark’s board as executive director.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

The most expensive honey in the world has a ‘Taranaki tang’

Source: Radio New Zealand

The two litre jar is going for roughly $500,000. It contains some of the rarest manuka honey in the world.

The two litre jar is going for roughly $500,000. It contains some of the rarest mānuka honey in the world. Photo: Naki Honey/Supplied

A New Zealand company has created what’s believed to be the world’s most expensive honey.

The Eternal Gold collection by Taranaki-based Naki Honey was inspired by archaeologists’ discovery of 3000-year-old honey sealed in Egyptian tombs that was still pefectly edible.

Just 73 jars have been produced, using honey from remote Taranaki bush. The honey is designed to last for centuries.

The Eternal Gold collection by Taranaki-based Naki Honey was inspired by archaeologists' discovery of 3,000-year-old honey sealed in Egyptian tombs that was still perfectly edible. This one goes for $1000.

The collection was inspired by archaeologists’ discovery of 3000-year-old honey sealed in Egyptian tombs. This jar goes for $1000. Photo: Naki Honey/Supplied

It uses Unique Mānuka Factor (UMF) 25+ honey, a grade so rare it’s only harvested when the weather and flowering conditions in Taranaki are just right which is about once every two years.

It’s also among the highest-grade mānuka in the world.

Naki Honey’s Derek Burchell-Burger said the handcrafted vessels doubled as art pieces and featured gold plated details.

Prices range depending on size with the smallest going for $1000 and a two litre jar going for roughly $500,000.

“Every two years, we get to develop a particularly potent strand of mānuka honey. So this is the first one ever, the inaugural range, and we’ve got three tiers available.

“It’s not just a jar of honey. We’re also doing our foray into art.

Naki Honey's Derek Burchell-Burger

Naki Honey’s Derek Burchell-Burger Photo: Naki Honey/Supplied

“It can be passed down the generations because it’s got amounts of that immunopotentiating chemical known as methylglyoxal in it.

“It does have a more stronger taste. It is a bit more herbal. We call it the Taranaki tang.”

Burchell-Burger said it was not designed to be used like regular honey a person would have on their morning toast, but similar to a whiskey collection that might be brought out for a special occasion.

The unveiling of the honey collection is taking place at the New Zealand Liberation Museum – Te Arawhata in northern France which is the only Kiwi museum outside Aotearoa.

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Why is Augustine being sold at The Outlet?

Source: Radio New Zealand

Augustine has become one of New Zealand Facebook's favourite fashion brands, known for its bright, floral and sparkly pieces.

Augustine has become one of New Zealand Facebook’s favourite fashion brands, known for its bright, floral and sparkly pieces. Photo: Supplied / Augustine

Over the past decade, Augustine has become one of New Zealand Facebook’s favourite fashion brands.

At regular intervals through the year, founder Kelly Coe would hype up and release one of the seasonal releases from its labels and thousands of women across the country would clamour to get their hands on the (usually) bright, (frequently) floral and (often) sparkly pieces.

Prices would range generally from about $100 to $200.

While the VIP Facebook group still has more than 20,000 members, the clamour has died down – and many were surprised to spot Augustine and its associated brands being stocked by discount retailer The Outlet in recent weeks, with prices starting at about $20.

So what’s going on, and why would the brand do this?

Retail consultant Chris Wilkinson said it was “very telling” of where the market was and had generated a lot of interest.

He said while Augustine had been a “darling” brand that was at times “euphoric”, particularly among its social media following, the move was reflective of the fact that there had been a slowdown in demand for its type of product. It closed its Takapuna shop.

“She’s got a very unique brand and culture that sits behind it… the way things are has been very challenging.”

He said The Outlet’s main focus was on selling distressed or overstocked items.

An Augustine top listed on The Outlet.

An Augustine top listed on The Outlet. Photo: Supplied / The Outlet

Stock such as the Augustine clothing could bring in different audiences who would not typically shop there, he said.

Something similar would sometimes happen at Reduced to Clear, he said, when it stocked mixers such as specialty tonic water much more cheaply than they would normally be available for.

There could be an effect on the brand, he said, but brands sometimes had a limited lifespan anyway. Huffer had been picked up by The Warehouse.

The Outlet is stocking a “Siri” dress for $19 while it is on the Augustine site for $49.99, albeit with a different colour skirt.

Bodo Lang, marketing expert at Massey University, said that could be an issue. “Selling identical products at very different prices can create serious problems for brands, as it risks alienating both consumers and retailers. Both are crucial for a brand’s survival. After all, no one likes discovering they have paid more than someone else for the same item.”

He said there was a risk to the brand.

“First, the discounts are substantial, often around 50 percent or slightly higher. Second, they apply to a wide range of garments, more than 150 in total, rather than a small, carefully selected few. Third, these discounted items are very easy to find online. Fourth, while Augustine’s own website states that its garments are available at two outlet stores, The Outlet website appears to list heavily discounted Augustine garments across far more than two stores – in fact, across most of New Zealand. This inconsistency poses a problem, as the availability of discounted products on The Outlet website does not align with the brand story presented on Augustine’s site.

“Collectively, these factors risk cheapening the brand. Deep and widespread discounts can make it harder to sell new-season items at full price, as customers learn that prices are likely to drop significantly within a few months. In addition, lower prices can attract a different clientele, and in fashion, social signalling is a powerful part of what consumers are really buying.”

Public relations consultant Chamanthie Sinhalage-Fonseka said there were other strong names selling via The Outlet who did it without cheapening their brand, such as Adidas and Birkenstock.

“But they are a different category from Augustine and their brand equity is created offshore. Brands also surf waves of consumer preferences and changing economic conditions in order to stay alive.

“Marc Jacobs has fallen in terms of designer prestige but as a result is more accessible to mid-range customers and can position themselves as top of mid-range rather than bottom of luxury.”

Augustine has been approached for comment.

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Sharemarket concern: ‘If it keeps building and building, it’ll blow’

Source: Radio New Zealand

Sharemarket, stockmarket generic

Despite warnings of a potential crash due to inflated AI share prices, markets around the world continue to hit records. Photo: 123RF

It would be good for markets to go through a small correction to avoid a bigger explosion, one fund manager says.

Despite warnings of a potential crash due to inflated AI share prices, markets around the world continue to hit records.

Murray Harris, head of KiwiSaver at Milford Asset Management, said it was a worry.

“The market is being buoyed by continuing prospects for lower interest rates… and companies that are doing well.

“There’s not a lot of reason for people to be thinking ‘oh this is going to end’ other than the professional investors like ourselves going ‘well this can’t last forever’.”

He said as prices pushed up, it would be useful to have occasional 10 to 15 percent falls.

“It would be healthy to have a bit of a pullback on markets and think of it like a pressure cooker. If it keeps building and building and building it’ll blow but if it lets off a little bit of steam, then we get a 10 percent or 15 percent pull back then the market can move higher again.”

But Rupert Carlyon, founder of Koura Wealth, said when adjusted for inflation the increases recorded did not look so dramatic.

“Over the last five or six years inflation has been about 35 percent so even a market that is up 35 percent today is basically where it was five years ago.”

He said even the big companies that seemed highly valued were strong on growth and return-on-equity measures. “I personally do not believe there has ever been a set of companies as strong in delivering the growth numbers that currently we have.”

He said there had been many warnings over the past five years that a market rally was unsustainable.

“We saw it when interest rates started going up, we saw it with the tech bubble kind of starting to burst a bit… every time it’s been proven wrong.”

What can investors do?

Harris said although the market felt “frothy” it was not a reason not to be invested.

“As an active manager, we can take protection through derivatives and we can move cash around and we’re doing that, and can look for opportunities outside the really highly inflated industries and assets. It kind of feels like it can’t keep going on forever, and it won’t.”

Some investors have moved money into assets such as gold. Harris said when he was in Sydney last week there was a line around the corner for a bullion dealer.

“That to me is a sign of a bubble, but it doesn’t mean the price can’t continue to go up… it does well when there is high inflation and a bit of geopolitical uncertainty because people go ‘well I have this physical thing and I can put it under my bed’, but at the end of the day it doesn’t generate any dividends or revenue or profits or income. You’re totally reliant on the person you sell it to being willing to pay more for it than you paid.”

He said people who were investing for the long term should look through the market movements.

“If you’ve got a 10-year view, we’ll see some sort of pullback at some point but if your goal hasn’t changed, your risk profile’s the same, then you stick with it.”

He said the market buoyancy seemed to be prompting a large number of transfers between KiwiSaver providers. “I think, with the confidence that people are getting from markets going up and their values going up and their balances getting bigger, they’re thinking ‘maybe I should do some more research’.”

Falling interest rates had also prompted people to move from term deposits to managed funds, he said.

Harris said he had seen a lot of money flow out of bank deposit into retail unit trust funds.

“We’ve seen record levels of flows into those from people that have taken money out of term deposits. That’s a sign that markets are at a toppy level.”

He said people need to understand the additional risk that came with investing in funds.

“We explain this to everyone who is investing with us, they could go down. You could be buying at a high point in the market. This is not going go be like your term deposit, that’s just going to keep your capital and give you a return.”

Carlyon said investors should try to ignore the noise. “Over the last five or six years there’s been a huge amount of negativity in the press. There is a lot of people that don’t like and don’t want to believe the current market rally… what we’ve seen is the only smart way to be invested is to stay invested.”

Do passive investments exacerbate the market movements?

Mike Taylor, founder of Pie Funds, said there was the potential for exchange-traded funds to exacerbate any potential fall.

There has been a big increase in passively invested funds in recent years, which aim to replicate a market index rather than outperforming.

“The interaction between an ETF and the underlying market can work a bit like the futures market and the cash market,” Taylor said.

“When volatility rises, usually to the downside, outflows from ETFs then lead to lower underlying stock prices, which then lead to more outflows.

“If we had a period when prices fall rapidly this could be problematic, particularly when you consider leveraged ETFs.”

Harris said an index fund had no option but to buy the expensive AI stocks.

“The weighting of those companies goes up every day in the index and they’ve got to buy more. But similarly they’ll have to sell more when the markets drop.”

He agreed leveraged ETFs could have an even bigger impact.

“When the market’s gone up it has to buy four or five times the exposure of the market… If the price is down it has to sell four or five times the value of the stock it’s holding. That could have some quite big moves.”

Dean Anderson, founder of Kernel, said the question was not whether money was actively or passively managed but whether there was new money coming into or out of equities.

“If it is net new buying demand into equities, that say previously has been in term deposits or cash, whether that goes into direct stocks, active, or passive funds – it is ultimately net buying power for equities which would support higher prices. The same is true in reverse.

“The active manager may argue they don’t have to buy or sell stocks when cash goes into or out of the fund – but in practice that isn’t the case. If they had a lot of withdrawals, they will be a seller, equally if they get a lot of applications they will have to buy as they risk having their performance lag if they sit on too much cash for too long.”

Carlyon said retail investors were also more likely to follow trends. They have become a much more dominant force in recent years.

“When I started my career a market move of 1 percent or 1.5 percent in a day was kind of unusual, whereas we’ve seen two or three days this week which have been over that number.”

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

New weight restrictions for larger pets taking domestic Air New Zealand flights

Source: Radio New Zealand

Pet carrier

Air NZ staff have been getting injured while trying to load heavier pets. (File photo) Photo: pixabay.com

Larger pets have been grounded on some of Air New Zealand’s domestic flights after a spate of injuries to staff as they try to load heavy carriers into aircraft holds.

Air New Zealand has introduced new size and weight restrictions for carriers on its smaller domestic flights. From next week, pets and carriers weighing more than a combined 60 kilograms will be grounded.

The changes had to be made for the safety of staff, Air NZ’s chief safety and integrity officer Nathan McGraw told Morning Report.

“Its a bit of a tough call… [we] appreciate this will be disappointing. It’s fair to say the number of larger pets is smaller in number.”

McGraw said there had been more than 50 injuries to staff in the past couple of years from loading large and bulky items into smaller aircraft holds.

“When you’re loading these carriers into confined spaces there’s a lot of moving, positioning and tilting – particularly if there’s a large animal inside that may move and shift which creates a risk of injury to our people and to the wellbeing of the pet.”

For anyone wanting to travel with an animal and carrier that weighed more than 60kg, McGraw said it was still possible, but they would need to go through a pet transport company.

“They work closely with our team,” he said, “and you can add the pet as you did in the past to your ticket, but it takes you through to those options.

“For a jet service we can carry those larger crates but through those transport companies.”

Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

$50 an hour, 12% superannuation: Australian recruiters target jobseekers

Source: Radio New Zealand

Beachgoers enjoy the sunset at Bondi beach during a heatwave in Sydney on December 19, 2019. A state of emergency was declared in Australia's most populated region on December 19 as an unprecedented heatwave fanned out-of-control bushfires, destroying homes and smothering huge areas with a toxic smoke. (Photo by FAROOQ KHAN / AFP)

Photo: AFP / Farooq Khan

Journalist Ged Cann says he started thinking about moving overseas out of concern over whether he would ever be able to build the kind of life he wanted in New Zealand.

“When it became clear the newly-elected National-led government was going to hand tax breaks back to property investors I decided the prospects for my generation affording a home and having a good life in New Zealand were limited.

“It was a choice between staying in a low-wage, high-cost-of-living country where half of my wage would go on mortgage repayments, or moving to a high-wage country with lower cost of living and more career options.”

He said he spoke to recruiters who said house prices and the high cost of living meant they struggled to attract and retain international talent, “hamstringing the likes of the tech and the international education sector”.

The Qantas Dreamliner.

In the year to March 2025, 47,734 migrants left New Zealand for Australia – 86 percent of them were New Zealand citizens. Photo: Supplied / Qantas

He initially applied for a job that would have been based in South East Asia but after he interviewed for the role he was offered a job in Melbourne, with support for the move.

“There are a lot more opportunities, and wages really are markedly higher. Adjusting for the exchange rate, my wage increased 31 percent after moving to Melbourne.

“I find the workforce are also more dynamic. I remember the day I arrived on the 6am flight out of Christchurch I sat in a café and found myself accidentally eavesdropping, and I was staggered at the number of young people coming and going, discussing business ideas, or new products, or start-ups they were involved in.”

He said the perks were better, too.

“Unions here are stronger, which means overtime payments and things like higher rates on weekends are enforced as a matter of course. The minimum superannuation contribution is also much higher here – 12 percent of earnings, compared to 3 percent for KiwiSaver. The difference that makes is massive, and you visibly see your retirement savings grow every fortnight.”

He is one of many New Zealanders who have made the leap for better work opportunities in Australia.

In the year to March 2025, the most recent for which data is available, 47,734 migrants left New Zealand for Australia, of whom 86 percent were New Zealand citizens.

Accounting for people moving the other way, the net loss was just under 30,000.

New Zealand’s annual net loss averaged about 30,000 a year during 2004 to 2013, and 3000 a year during 2014 to 2019, Stats NZ said.

Australian recruiters are working hard to appeal to New Zealand job hunters, as this country’s labour market continues to struggle.

There are ads on Trade Me from Australian firms wanting to hire New Zealanders including air conditioning technicians on $45 to $55 an hour with assistance with relocation and a sign-on bonus, carpenters, land development surveyors, technicians, civil engineers and roofers.

“The number of job listings that contain the key words of ‘Australia’ or some combination of ‘move/relocate to Australia’ is small, accounting for about 0.05 percent of all listings annually. While we’ve seen the total number of these listings gradually increase over the last five years, there’s not enough data to draw meaningful conclusions from,” a spokesperson said.

Seek’s New Zealand site offers the option of searching for roles in Australia, and there are almost 18,000 available.

A recent Seek posting that was emailed to New Zealand jobhunters asked teachers to relocate to Victoria from New Zealand and earn up to A$118,063 a year plus 12 percent superannuation.

Seek said the number of New Zealand applications for Australian roles was higher now than before Covid. Just over 1 percent of all applicants for Australian jobs are in New Zealand.

About a quarter of New Zealanders were applying for jobs in Queensland. That was followed by Victoria at 22.5 percent.

Just over 11 percent were applying for trades and services roles.

Kiwibank chief economist Jarrod Kerr said he had recently been at a building industry conference where participants told him they expected many of the people featured as “apprentices of the year” would go to Australia once they finished their training.

“That’s just one example, there have been others telling me that… accountants, lawyers… it’s frustrating for them to train them up and they leave.”

Westpac chief economist Kelly Eckhold said the Australian labour market was a lot stronger than New Zealand’s and had been for some time.

That was helping to drive stronger population growth there, too.

“We tend to find with net migration is that it is inversely correlated with the unemployment rate differential.

“So with our unemployment rate now at 5.3 percent versus the 4.3 percent there, that reflects a sizeable difference in terms of labour market demand and conditions. Usually our unemployment rate would be a bit lower than Australia’s.”

He said the situation was likely to continue for at least the next six months.

“Our forecast for the unemployment rate suggests another increase in the unemployment rate in the fourth quarter, which is where we’re sitting now in reality. So 5.4 percent. And my colleagues in Australia have got much lower unemployment rate forecasts, peaking at around about 4.5 percent there and thereabouts.”

It should start to narrow towards the middle of next year, he said.

“That’s when we are expecting to see much stronger employment growth.”

People were being paid more in Australia, he said.

“The per capita income level in Australia is stronger than here. So on average, that would be the case. Quite difficult, I think, to make direct comparisons.

“The tax and superannuation differences are significant between New Zealand and Australia. So you have to sort of look a little bit beyond the actual wage rate or the monthly pay, I think. That’s true… also, you have to remember that, you know, the cost of living is also higher in Australia, particularly if you want to buy a house.

“If you were going to move from, say, Auckland to Sydney, for example, you would have to price in a noticeably higher cost for accommodation. And certainly, if you expected to buy a house, you would probably find that you would need to trade down relative to what you think you could afford in New Zealand. “

Sign up for Money with Susan Edmunds, a weekly newsletter covering all the things that affect how we make, spend and invest money.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Ōtara ‘locked out’ in stoush over local board leadership roles

Source: Radio New Zealand

The Ōtara Papatoetoe local board for 2025 - 2028 where Papatoetoe hold both leadership roles regarding the chair and deputy positions.

The Ōtara Papatoetoe local board for 2025 – 2028 where Papatoetoe hold both leadership roles regarding the chair and deputy positions. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

Ōtara elected members say being refused any local board’s leadership roles is like a “slap in the face” and broke a long-standing tradition of sharing the top positions between suburbs.

At the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board inauguration on Tuesday night, the newly elected Papatoetoe Action-Team used its four-seat majority to secure both the chair and deputy chair positions.

This left Ōtara’s three elected members without leadership roles for the first time since the Auckland Super City was formed in 2010.

Prior to the inauguration, Ōtara representatives – Apulu Reece Autagavaia, Topou Folau, and Li’amanaia Lorenzo Kaisara – said they had walked out of a meeting that morning over the issue.

Apulu, who chaired the board in the previous term, said the decision risked dividing the community and being a “tyranny of the majority”.

“They had a choice to involve Ōtara. If they go ahead with this decision, they’re disrespecting Ōtara. They’re saying the people of Ōtara are an afterthought.”

He said previous boards had deliberately shared the top roles to reflect the area’s two distinct communities of interest.

“When I was chair, we represented both Ōtara and Papatoetoe.”

At the meeting, the Papatoetoe representatives voted for the same nominee, confirming Kushma Nair as chair and Paramjeet Singh as deputy chair for the full three-year term.

Friends and family attend the inauguration as Ōtara community members voice their hurt and disappointment over Ōtara representatives being shut out of leadership.

Friends and family attend the inauguration as Ōtara community members voice their hurt and disappointment over Ōtara representatives being shut out of leadership. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

The decision prompted loud public outbursts and cries of “unfair” and “racist” from sections of the audience.

Supporters of Ōtara members stood and shouted as the votes were counted, accusing the Papatoetoe side of “locking Ōtara out.”

Newly elected chair Kushma Nair told Local Democracy Reporting he understood the emotion in the room but asked the community to give the board time to prove itself.

“People in Ōtara should not feel that we will leave anybody out. We are here to serve everyone,” he says. “It doesn’t belong to one party or any other party, we are ratepayers the same as you. We have to work together to achieve things in our community.”

Community members, friends and families attend the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board inauguration at Manukau Civic Building to support the newly elected members.

Community members, friends and families attend the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board inauguration at Manukau Civic Building to support the newly elected members. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

Nair said all members, new and returning, would need to collaborate to achieve results.

“We have the experience of the three Ōtara members on board, and with that combined knowledge, I think the board can achieve a lot,” he said.

“It’s our first meeting. Over time, things will gel once we start doing the work on the ground.”

Prior to the meeting, Topou Folau, who was re-elected to the board, said the outcome ignored every opportunity to work together.

Ōtara representatives re-elected for another term, Li'amanaia Lorenzo Kaisara, Topou Folau and Apulu Reece Autagavaia.

Ōtara representatives re-elected for another term, Li’amanaia Lorenzo Kaisara, Topou Folau and Apulu Reece Autagavaia. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

“It felt like we were told, ‘No, we’ll run things, you can support us to look good in front of the community.'”

Li’amanaia Lorenzo Kaisara, another re-elected board member, said it was a missed opportunity to showcase how they can work together, despite their political affiliations.

“I’m hurt for our people in Ōtara. I feel Ōtara has been belittled and not even considered in the leadership.”

According to Autagavaia, since Auckland Council’s formation in 2010, the chair and deputy roles have traditionally been split between Ōtara and Papatoetoe subdivisions.

During the meeting, Ōtara members proposed sharing leadership, with each subdivision holding the chair for half the term, but were outvoted four-to-three by the Papatoetoe subdivision.

From left: Sandeep Saini, Kunal Bhalla, Chair Kushma Nair and Deputy Chair Paramjeet Singh at the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board inauguration.

From left: Sandeep Saini, Kunal Bhalla, Chair Kushma Nair and Deputy Chair Paramjeet Singh at the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board inauguration. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

Fuli and Filipaina both addressed the meeting, acknowledging the tension but urging cooperation.

“People are hurt and worried about what the future looks like for them,” Fuli said.

“If the chair is from Papatoetoe, then the deputy should be from Ōtara to honour that unity.”

Lotu said she and Filipaina would act as mediators.

Manukau Ward councillors Lotu Fuli and Alf Filipaina tell the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board they will act as mediators to help members find a way forward.

Manukau Ward councillors Lotu Fuli and Alf Filipaina tell the Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board they will act as mediators to help members find a way forward. Photo: Mary Afemata / LDR

“They can always change their minds in time once relationships build,” she said. “Alf and I will play that role, to help heal what’s happened and bring the board together.”

Papatoetoe Action Team spokesperson Kunal Bhalla said the decision followed due process and reflected voters’ will.

“The Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board represents one united community. While our subdivisions exist for electoral purposes, our work is for all residents, from Ōtara through to Papatoetoe,” he said. “Our focus is on outcomes, not boundaries.”

Bhalla said the Papatoetoe Action Team won all four seats in its subdivision, giving it a clear mandate for change.

“The election of a Chair and Deputy Chair is a democratic process among elected members, not a public vote. Within that framework, our team proposed both positions to ensure continuity and clear direction for the term ahead,” he said.

He acknowledged previous boards had shared leadership between the two suburbs but said there was no formal requirement to do so.

Bhalla said the team acknowledged former chair Apulu’s service but believed in rotating leadership and valuing all members’ perspectives.

“The idea of ‘tyranny of the majority’ misrepresents a democratic outcome.

“The mandate for change came from the voters, and we intend to honour it through fair, inclusive governance.”

The Ōtara-Papatoetoe Local Board was one of only a few in Auckland with formal subdivisions, created under the Super City reforms to protect distinct “communities of interest.”

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Canterbury farmer urges government to act as consent costs spiral

Source: Radio New Zealand

Mid Canterbury farmer David Clark says a transition is required between the old RMA rules and the incoming new legislation

Mid Canterbury farmer David Clark says a transition is required between the old RMA rules and the incoming new legislation. Photo: Supplied

A Mid Canterbury farmer wants the government to live up to its word and help farmers who are “wasting” large sums of money on a consent process in limbo.

It has been seven weeks since David Clark decided to go public on his frustration with the resource consent process and its “outrageous costs”.

Clark said he has since heard from many other farming families “facing the same, or worse situation than us”.

“We all know the problem. We all acknowledge the need for a solution,” Clark said.

Clark said Prime Minister Christopher Luxon has repeatedly said his government backed farmers and is calling on him to “act on those words”.

The government’s planned Resource Management Act (RMA) reforms must start with an urgent pause on the enforcement of consenting rules – sentiment that was supported by Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour and Act MP Andrew Hoggard on a recent visit to his farm.

“It is utter madness for farming families to be expected to continue wasting these large sums of money on a process that will be redundant, or significantly changed in the near future.

“The solution is an extension to all existing consents until the new rules are in place.”

Clark has a mixed arable, seed, and livestock operation near Ashburton that has held a consent since 2017 and was awarded an A-grade environmental audit in 2024.

He estimated he will spend about $60,000 to get to the mid-point in the process of seeking consent to continue farming, and is facing between $200,000-300,000 if his application is fully publicly notified and requires a hearing.

Mid Canterbury farmers met with Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour and Act MP Andrew Hoggard in September. [From left] Colin Hurst, Ian McKenzie, Hon Andrew Hoggard, David Clark, Hon David Seymour, Kate Ackland, David Ackland, Terry Clark and Phill Everest.

Mid Canterbury farmers met with Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour and Act MP Andrew Hoggard in September. [From left] Colin Hurst, Ian McKenzie, Andrew Hoggard, David Clark, David Seymour, Kate Ackland, David Ackland, Terry Clark and Phill Everest. Photo: Supplied

His comments follow a Federated Farmers survey released last week that showed four out of five farmers are worried about gaining or renewing consents.

Federated Farmers freshwater spokesperson Colin Hurst said the findings reveal a “damning picture of a system that’s simply not working”.

“Our survey makes for incredibly sobering reading, as it’s shown us the true scale of the consenting problems,” Hurst said.

“It was staggering to learn the average bill across the country for gaining a new consent has hit nearly $45,000 and renewal permits were averaging $28,000.

“It’s even worse for Canterbury farmers, who are forking out over $60,000.

“The whole process has become so uncertain and complex that most farmers now must rely entirely on consultants and expert advisors.”

With thousands of consents due to expire in the coming months, Hurst said the situation is urgent and requires immediate action.

“How are [farmers] supposed to have the confidence to keep investing in their businesses if they don’t even know whether they’ll be allowed to keep farming next year?”

RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop said the government is giving active consideration to the transition from the old RMA system to the new system.

“Mr Clark can rest assured that he and others in a similar situation are being heard,” Bishop said.

“We will have more to say in the coming weeks as the new legislation and framework is released.”

The new system is expected before Parliament by December, with plans to pass it into law by mid-2026 and take effect by 2027.

Regional councils must continue operating under current law until then.

In early October, Bishop sent a letter to regional councils requesting they use “sensible judgement” in managing consents until the new legislation was in place.

In his letter, Bishop said he expected councils to be “seeking opportunities to streamline consenting processes, reduce onerous requirements wherever possible, and ease the consenting burden”.

Environment Canterbury responded in a letter, from then chairperson Craig Pauling, deputy chair Deon Swiggs, and chief executive Stefanie Rixecker, that expressed support with the Government’s reform agenda.

ECan said it was taking practical steps to improve consenting processes while upholding its statutory duties, and welcomed a meeting with Ministers to discuss details of the transition plan.

Bishop said officials will be engaging with ECan as part of discussing and preparing for the transition.

“I don’t intend to meet with every regional council – it simply isn’t practical,” Bishop said.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Large service station planned on some of NZ’s best growing land

Source: Radio New Zealand

Caption: A concept image of the service station. Plans include a cafe, truck stop and 62 car parks.

A concept image of the service station. Plans include a cafe, truck stop and 62 car parks. Photo: Supplied/ LDR

A resource consent for a service station to be built on some of New Zealand’s most fertile soils, beside the Hawke’s Bay Expressway, has been lodged with the Hastings District Council.

Hamachek Holdings’ plans for the site on the corner of State Highway 2 and Evenden Rd, Twyford, include a truck stop, service station, retail service area, cafe and fruit shop facilities.

A public notice of the project said about 29,570m3 of earthworks would be required to build the centre.

It would have four-lanes of pumps at a truck stop, eight lanes of pumps on a service station forecourt, underground petrol and diesel tanks, EV charging stations.

It would also require a two-way combined entry and exit access from Evenden Rd, road widening and changes to the SH2 and Evenden Rd roundabout.

The plans also include 62 carparks, 12 truck parks, loading spaces and pedestrian footpaths.

A service station on the corner of Evenden Road and State Highway 2 is surrounded by horticulture.

A service station on the corner of Evenden Road and State Highway 2 is surrounded by horticulture. Photo: Google Maps

The land is classed as Plains Production land, a council zoning that recognises it as a place with nationally significant growing soils.

Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum said everyone could now have their say before a decision was made.

“That openness is a strength of the system as it ensures people can be heard and decisions are made with a clear understanding of our community’s values,” Schollum said.

“This proposal is classed as a non-complying activity, which means it must meet a very high bar to be approved.

“The Heretaunga Plains are among the most fertile soils in the country, and our District Plan is designed to protect that while allowing fair consideration of any application under the law.”

The rear of the site was currently occupied by a residential dwelling, while the front was used for horticultural purposes.

The fuel station will include a separate cafe and shop.

The fuel station will include a separate cafe and shop. Photo: LDR / Supplied

Hamachek said in resource consent documents it had consulted with multiple organisations about its plans, including adjacent landowners Delegat’s Winery, which raised concerns about proximity, night-time activity, light spill, and visual impact on winery operations.

The documents also show community group Save the Plains acknowledged the value of a truck stop somewhere on the Expressway, but opposed the use of Plains Production Zone land at Hamachek’s preferred location.

Submissions to Hastings District Council on the resource consent application close at 5pm on December 3.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand

Ideas for what to do with Tōmoana Showgrounds in Hastings are being sought – and Pandaland will be one submission

Source: Radio New Zealand

Retired businessman Max Patmoy says he will be re-presenting his vision and request for the use of a portion of the Tōmoana Showgrounds to new Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum.

Retired businessman Max Patmoy says he will be re-presenting his vision and request for the use of a portion of the Tōmoana Showgrounds to new Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum. Photo: Local Democracy Reporting

The chance to shape the future of the Tōmoana Showgrounds in Hastings has arrived, and a man who wants it to include a park for giant pandas says he’ll be taking the opportunity to revive his vision.

The Hastings District Council, which purchased the showgrounds from the Hawke’s Bay A&P Society in 2023, is asking residents to help shape a 10-year master plan for its future.

For Max Patmoy, it’s another opportunity to get his ambitious plans for Pandaland across the line.

Patmoy, a retired Hawke’s Bay businessman, last November announced a bid to build a new tourism and conservation park in a $17.5 million facility which would house two giant panda bears on loan from China.

It would be a one-of-a-kind facility in New Zealand and Patmoy’s preferred location was Hastings, which has a sister city, Guilin, in China.

He said at the time “there are a lot of barriers, but none that are impenetrable”.

Patmoy said he met last year with the then Hastings Mayor Sandra Hazlehurst and Hastings District Council CEO Nigel Bickle to present his vision and request the use of a portion of the Tōmoana Showgrounds for $1 a year.

“I was shown the door,” Patmoy said.

“I’ve had more feasibility studies done since then, so I’m going to have another go at presenting my plan to a different mayor.”

He said he had also presented it to Palmerston North Mayor Grant Smith and had a meeting with the new Napier City Council Mayor Richard McGrath later this month.

The Napier council is seeking expressions of interest for the future ownership, operation, or redevelopment of the National Aquarium of NZ, which Patmoy believes could also be another strong spot for Pandaland.

The future of the aquarium is being weighed up due to the cost to ratepayers and ageing facilities.

Hastings mayor Wendy Schollum said the plan for the showgrounds wasn’t about spending big.

“It’s about thinking smart and exploring ways the showrounds can serve our people’s aspirations while helping to pay its own way through events, recreation, and activities which will keep it vibrant and loved for generations to come.

“Ideas that would change the showgrounds’ character, such as housing or large-scale commercial development, aren’t on the table.

“We’re asking our community to help shape what the future looks like, but there are some clear boundaries.

“The showgrounds will stay in public ownership, continue to host iconic events and activities like the Farmers’ Market, and remain a place people can freely enjoy,” Schollum said.

When the A&P Society held its first show at the site in 1925, it was called the Tōmoana Showground.

The Tōmoana Showgrounds is home to the popular weekly Farmers’ Market.

The Tōmoana Showgrounds is home to the popular weekly Farmers’ Market. Photo: Local Democracy Reporting

The name slipped from common usage and was eventually referred to as the Hawke’s Bay Showgrounds.

In 2017, the official name was reinstated and welcomed by the Tōmoana whānau, whose ancestor Henare Tōmoana once owned 20,000 acres of the Heretaunga land.

Tamatea Pōkai Whenua said the showgrounds was a landscape rich in memory, connection, and enduring community spirit.

Chairperson Pōhatu Paku acknowledged the Tōmoana whānau.

“They, alongside other prominent whānau, have long been leaders, hosts, and unwavering supporters of this community.

“We recognise the importance of honouring the past while embracing the opportunities that lie ahead,” Paku said.

“The showgrounds stand as a reminder of what can be achieved when whānau, hapū, and community come together in unity and purpose – a legacy that Tamatea Pōkai Whenua is very proud of.”

The plan is being prepared on behalf of Hastings District Council and the Tōmoana Showgrounds Charitable Trust, which was established to manage the showgrounds following its purchase.

It will guide how the 40ha site is used, balancing heritage, culture, events, recreation, and sustainability.

Former Hastings mayor and Trust chairwoman Sandra Hazlehurst said consultation with the community and stakeholders, including mana whenua, leaseholders, and event coordinators, would ensure the plan reflected the way people use and value the showgrounds.

“The showgrounds has long been a place where our rural and urban lives come together, from the A&P Show and Horse of the Year, to the farmers’ market, concerts and events. We want residents to tell us what they love about the space, what could be improved, and what they’d like to see in the future,” she said.

It will also help determine the types of reserve status applied to ensure it remains a publicly owned green space for generations to come.

Schollum said for her, the annual A&P Show was the closest thing Hastings had to Disneyland.

“The showgrounds had the rides, the animals, and that sense of wonder,” she said.

“I still remember the thrill of the spinning top rides, learning about our agricultural sector, and the joy of holding baby chicks for the first time.”

The decision to buy the land received strong public support, with more than 90 percent of submitters backing the move to secure it for the community.

Residents can provide their feedback online on the Hastings District Council’s website or fill in a written submission at one of the Hastings libraries, or at Council’s customer service centre in Lyndon Rd, by midnight on 16 November.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.

– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand