Source: Radio New Zealand
Advisory group chair Sunny Kaushal intentional misinformation has been “weaponised” to undermine the campaign. RNZ / Samuel Rillstone
- Ministerial advisory group criticised for ‘lavish’ spending
- It spent $24,000 on well-catered ‘stakeholder engagement meetings’
- Advisory group chairman defends the group’s work, saying it’s under budget and delivering change
The ministerial advisory group for victims of retail crime faces criticism for spending almost $24,000 on a series of well-catered meetings around New Zealand.
Rock melon, goat’s cheese and prosciutto crostini, mini chicken and leek savouries, and $9 bottles of Coke are among the items served to guests during meetings led by group chairman Sunny Kaushal at venues around the country.
Kaushal said the stakeholder engagement meetings were part of his mission to fix retail crime in New Zealand and he was disappointed to see “intentional misinformation being weaponised” to distract from the advisory group’s progress.
Information provided to RNZ’s Checkpoint by the Ministry of Justice revealed the bill for 22 meetings between February and November came in at $23,915.
Two meetings in Auckland – one in February and one in July – each cost more than $4000, while another cost more than $3000.
The advisory group’s spending had previously come under scrutiny, including its $100,000-a-year central Auckland office space.
Kaushal also billed $230,000 for his first year of work, at a daily rate of $920. He said the group ran under its annual budget of $1.8 million, paid for from the proceeds of crime fund.
Under his government contract, Kaushal can work up to 250 days a year and invoiced for the maximum amount. The group was set up in 2024 for two years.
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith suggests the meetings “probably had too many scones”. RNZ / Mark Papalii
‘Probably too many scones’
At a recent select committee meeting during Parliament’s scrutiny week, Labour MPs queried the spend on the February meeting, which was $4075.
Justice Minister Paul Goldsmith, who was present, admitted to the NZ Herald the event was “clearly over-catered” and “probably had too many scones”. He did not respond to RNZ for this story.
The costs also included charges for chairs, paper plates a lectern and an AV technician.
Fifty cheese-and-tomato sandwiches cost $175, as did 50 chicken-and-cheese sandwiches.
Bottles of Coke and Sprite – 2.5 litres – which cost about $5.50 at the supermarket were charged to the group at $9 each. About 80 people attended.
In March, a two-hour meeting for 150 people, held in South Auckland, cost $3980, including $800 for venue hire and $120 for security. The $3060 catering bill for the two-hour meeting wasn’t broken down.
In July, another two-hour meeting in Auckland for 80 people, attended by Goldsmith and Associate Justice Minister Nicole McKee, cost $4013.
That included chairs and equipment hire. The catering came to $2063.
Individual items were not costed, although they were the same food offerings as listed at the February meeting.
Other meetings around the country, most of which ran for two hours, were attended by between 9-70 people.
A Christchurch meeting in July spent $750 on hiring space at the Little Andromeda Theatre for a two-hour meeting with 40 people.
In September, 30 people went to a two-hour meeting at the Taupō Yacht Club, where catering cost about $545.
Twenty rock melon, goats cheese and prosciutto crostini were $60, as were 20 onion, blue cheese and walnut crostini. Thirty mini vol-au-vents were $104, and 30 mini chicken-and-leek savouries cost $91.
According to social media posts, meetings were generally attended by the likes of police, local cambers of commerce and other businesspeople.
‘Consulting by food’
Labour MP Duncan Webb questioned the spending on food at the meetings.
“It just sounds like he’s spending government funding lavishly,” he said. “This is not a corporate marketing campaign.
Labour MP Duncan Webb also questioned the spending on the public meetings. VNP / Phil Smith
“It’s a ministerial advisory group that’s expected to come up with thoughtful ideas, including consulting with the community.
“I haven’t really seen consulting with the community by food as a technique.”
The money would be better spent in the justice system, including on preventing crime elsewhere.
Catered meetings were not the way proper consulting should be, according to Webb.
RNZ tried to contact Kaushal to ask about the spending and for more information about the meetings.
He sent a statement saying he was proud of the advisory group’s work, which had received strong appreciation from retailers across New Zealand.
“We are making a difference,” he said. “We are delivering tougher consequences for offenders.
“We are seeing positive results and making sure no one feels unsafe at work. We are on the right direction and we still have more work to do.”
Kaushal said the group had delivered five “legislative-ready major policy papers” – addressing citizens’ arrests, strengthening trespass laws and allowing retailers to use pepper spray to defend themselves.
He said the reforms were strong, practical and evidence-based.
“We are well under budget and have underspent. Any expenditure on stakeholder engagement meetings complies with the [Ministry of Justice’s] entertainment and sensitive expenditure guidance.
“I am on a mission. My focus is on the bigger goal, fixing retail crime in New Zealand, which is costing $2.7 billion per year.
“It’s disappointing to see intentional misinformation being weaponised in an attempt to distract from the substantial progress we are making.
“Some people don’t want to see change and prefer to play politics. That’s their choice, I’m focused on delivering results.”
Ministerial advisory groups have been set up to provide expert advice to the current government on issues ranging from aged-care funding to trans-national crime and school property.
The most recent group announced will advise Associate Health Minister Casey Costello on long-term reform of the aged-care system. It has nine members, plus a chairperson – former Labour Health Minister David Cunliffe.
Costello’s office told Checkpoint the group was expected to begin work in January, and provide a final report with advice and recommendations in mid-2026.
A ministerial advisory group on transnational, serious and organised crime, also set up by Costello, had just eight months to complete its work.
It was led by Steve Symon, a senior partner at Auckland law firm Meredith Connell, and had four other members with experience across government, law enforcement, regulation and the private sector.
The Ministry of Justice told Checkpoint the group released seven reports and the total amount paid in fees to the five members was $204,355.
It spent $493,013 on its work and $180,179 was paid for three fixed-term positions – a principal adviser, senior adviser and an administrator.
Like the MAG on victims of retail crime, the MAG on transnational, serious and organised crime was funded from the Proceeds of Crime Fund.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand