Source: Radio New Zealand
Rajinder has been accused of murdering Gurjit Singh in Dunedin in January last year. RNZ
The man accused of murdering Dunedin’s Gurjit Singh lied to police and left DNA evidence at the scene, the Crown has alleged.
The man, known only as Rajinder, is on trial at the High Court for murdering Singh, who was found dead on the lawn of his home in January last year after being stabbed more than 40 times.
Rajinder’s defence lawyer maintained his client had no reason to kill Singh and there was no animosity between the men.
In closing arguments, prosecutor Richard Smith said the jury could not be left with any uncertainty about his guilt.
He said a forensic expert had testified that blood samples taken in and around Singh’s home were 500,000 million times more likely to be Rajinder’s than a random person.
“His blood and hair in the scene. His hair in the victim’s hands, his injury and the thumb of the glove left at the scene. Him buying a murder kit. Him saying he didn’t even know where the victim lived yet here he is searching out a route to the victim’s house on the night of the murder,” he said.
“Apply your common sense, it’s not rocket science.”
Rajinder lied to police about how he cut his hand, changing his story from a chainsaw accident to a bike crash, Smith said.
Smith said the wound was instead consistent with a sharp object like a knife or glass, not the sharp rock Rajinder claimed was to blame when he tried to pop a wheelie on his bike and the front tyre came off.
A doctor had raised serious doubts about the wound, saying there was no grazing, no bruising and no abrasions from an apparent fall onto gravel, he said.
Smith said Rajinder again lied to the police when he was asked about other injuries and did not refer to “impressive bruising” on his abdomen and bruising on his hip.
The violent attack happened shortly before Singh’s wife was due to arrive from India to live with him – the same woman who rejected a proposal from Rajinder.
Smith said that rejection, as well as Singh rejecting Rajinder’s plan to marry his sister, was motive for murder.
Smith described the attack as brutal and violent, saying the person who committed the murder knew him and was determined to kill him, chasing him out of his own home.
Rajinder bought gloves from Bunnings and a knife and neck gaiter from Hunting and Fishing the day before the murder but did not tell police during his interview, he said.
Smith said the thumb of the glove was found at the scene, where it appeared to have been detached during the attack.
He said Rajinder also lied when he told police that he did not know when Singh lived, despite searching multiple times for the man’s address on his phone about a month before the attack and again that night.
The search included plotting out directions to Singh’s house that went along back roads where he would be less likely to be seen, he said.
Rajinder told police that he always took his wife to Mosgiel for driving lessons but Smith said her phone only showed her going there on the day before and on the day of Singh’s death.
Instead of a late driving lesson, the Crown suggested he went there to create an alibi or dispose of evidence after murdering Gurjit Singh.
The defence would deliver its closing remarks on Tuesday afternoon.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
– Published by EveningReport.nz and AsiaPacificReport.nz, see: MIL OSI in partnership with Radio New Zealand